“Many argue that justice delayed is justice denied, and that justice includes the scrutiny of those responsible for upholding it,” Christopher Pyne, Opposition justice spokesman, told the Herald Sun. He said press freedom must be defended, as long as national security is not at risk, and that the Australian media has a stellar reputation of not crossing boundaries when it comes to sensitive national security concerns.

Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance Federal Secretary Christoper Warren told the Herald Sun that his group is very concerned about the proposal, as Keelty's speech indicates he does not understand the role of the media.

Michael Pearce, vice president for Victorian Council for Civil Liberties, SC, called Keelty's proposal “a ridiculous suggestion” and “an appalling idea.”