Before news of O'Shea leaving the paper went public, Hiller had already made it clear that Stanton was the top candidate for the job, executives and journalists told The New York Times. Those sources have been granted anonymity, as they fear retaliation for discussing the situation.

However, some of Stanton's colleagues have gone to Hiller, asking him not to choose Stanton, as many did not believe he has the stature or experience to run a top U.S. newsroom, the sources told The New York Times, which Hiller also confirmed. Stanton, formerly The Los Angeles Times' innovation editor, had been a reporter and editor in business news.

Stanton told The New York Times that he needs to convince staffers he is not Hiller's puppet, as O'Shea had done before him.

For more on this topic, view a previous article from our partner site, Editorsweblog.org.